|
For
good or evil, advertising works. As an industry, it is a far better
model for producing organizations capable of creating change than
the bureaucratic or biomedical model we're used to. And there
is much we can learn from both advertising's corporate culture
and its craft.
|
|
Advertising
agencies effectively and, for the most part, efficiently spend
over 100 billion dollars a year creating and distributing messages
which have an almost magical catalytic effect, especially research
shows, on people who claim to be unmoved by advertising. They
are efficient shapers of facts which they convert gracefully into
emotion. They tap regularly into an invisible world of digital
information to produce and deliver low-content messages often
with blistering effect.
Advertising
agencies have the leverage we need to change our way of thinking
and acting. The best of them have successfully combined left brain
and right, science and art, and head and heart into a relatively
balanced unit of talent, diversity and drive. To boil it down
to its basic transformational process, advertising agencies have
account people whose job is to think like the client. And creative
departments which, when they're running right, have the job of
pulling the clients caution into the realms of the unseen.
|
|
Advertising
is the ultimate multidisciplinary practice. Along with the analytical
people who tailor mountains of statistical and demographic information,
the advertising business I grew up in is comprised of people from a
wide and varied cross section of American life. Along with the MBA's
and other business types, there are all manner of renegades: artists,
psychologists, ex-cab drivers, house painters, messenger boys, mailmen
and occasionally shady denizens of the deep. There are fastidious obsessors
over details, researchers, accountants, clerks, coordinators and deadline
watchers. There are art directors, photographers, renderers, assemblers
and writers. There are account representatives who must know something
about everything and use it to represent the client's interests in the
morning and the agency's interest in the afternoon.
Advertising
agencies are successful because they are such a hodgepodge of characters,
abilities and ideas. With so many different kinds of people sharing
objectives as well as office space, an advertising agency is, when it's
working right, a good example of a healthy community.
What
makes this particular community healthy is not only its focus on the
production of an actual product, it is also a shared character and culture
in the workplace. Employees work toward a common goal in cross-functional
teams copywriter, art director, researcher, account manager
all using left brain and right. They all know how success is defined
and what is expected of them if they wish to succeed.
Advertising
agencies are often quirky places with singular customs and business
styles. Some agencies are known for their dress codes, plush carpeting
and wood panel work spaces. Others are known for their blue jean clad
staff and exposed brick and pipe interiors. One of today's most successful
advertising giants prides itself on its utter lack of individual work
spaces, instead every employee gets a personal computer, a phone jack
and the opportunity to work whenever they want. One agency maintains
a sixty-year tradition of keeping a bowl of fresh apples on every reception
desk; another, in honor of its first client, a cranberry grower, sends
every employee a ten-pound bag of cranberries every Christmas. For a
big business, advertising agencies tend to reflect all the foibles and
charms of the people who comprise them.
It's
small wonder that more than most other professions, advertising is in
touch with the consuming American public. They're them. What's more,
they know how to talk about and demonstrate benefits. More than politicians,
more than pollsters, advertising people know what the public wants and
how to get its attention.
The
advertising business culture encourages and even rewards risk. Advertising
agencies may talk a blue streak about research and planning. This is
a profitable advertising sideline and research makes clients feel secure.
But in the end, the production of every multimillion dollar television
advertising campaign is an incredible act of faith. It involves the
mixing of words and images, camera angles and character actors, nods,
winks, whispers, music and sound effects into an incalculable stew
the recipe for which is forever hidden from view.
Those
who want to bring about social, environmental or behavioral change love
the idea that marketing might be some kind of magic. So, they turns
to advertising agencies and marketing firms with their substantial state
and federal dollars. But the reality of the hocus-pocus that produces
the marketing brew is frightening to the medical mind. As a result,
public health clients often end up fixated on that part of the marketing
process that is closest to their own biomedical model: research, analysis
and evaluation. Breaking the problem down and looking at it from as
many angles as possible gives the health practioner the illusion of
some kind of control.
A
curious thing happens when you unite the already methodical approach
of analytical science with the cumbersome machinery of a government
bureaucracy, and then match this contraption up to an advertising agency.
A sobering malaise sets in on both sides which all but neutralizes the
creative fever which makes advertising a powerful catalyst for change.
Successful
businesses are well aware of the primacy of risk and serendipity in
their success. If we want to help foster rapid and positive change in
the world, we have to first change our bureaus and departments into
organizations with shared goals and values. We should rise above the
level of administrative functions and create climates where not only
products but personalities, boldness and fortuity are more likely to
flourish.
|